Global

Improve Cosmetic Crate

in Suggestions1 post2 reactions25

Zacxry
Elite
ArtisanMember
Posts
648
Reactions received
206

joined

Awards

Marked as Global but this excludes Creative's Cosmetic Crate.

Currently all rewards are just in one massive pool together for you to win 1 at random on opening the crate. Getting any specific item you might want from this can be quite unrealistic and I think a lot of people aren't really jumping at the opportunity to open the crate as a result. This issue is also only added to whenever we get crate specific cosmetics such as the Halloween plushie set during the Spooky crate this month.

During a normal month there is a 1/267 chance you would get any specific item with no form of duplicate protection. Using the October 2026 version of the cosmetic crate as an example of one with added unique items, these odds change to 1/297 with 30/297 being the unique plushies, again with no protection from duplicates. With the way the crate currently works that makes getting all of these unique items while they are available quite unreasonable and as mentioned before, I think a lot of people don't even try because of how unreasonable it is. This pool will also only continue to increase as Minecraft adds more mobs which ultimately results in more Disguises, Pets, and Plushies.

The crate should roll for a category of item first (Glow, Plushie, Particle, Disguise, Pet) and then pull a reward from that category. This way you can then independently choose odds for each category rather than it fully being determined by how many of each item type there is. For a normal month this might not cause much difference to what it is now, but I think for months with unique items added, they should be their own category that has boosted odds compared to everything else that is available year round, making it more realistic and enticing to open cosmetic crates for those rewards.

Another factor is the lack of duplicate protection. Considering ranks already give a decent number of pets and disguises, the longer you play and open cosmetic crates, the more likely it is that you'll receive something you already have which in a lot of situations will be useless to you and may be hard to sell (in terms of pets, disguises, and particles, which make up a large majority of the crate). Once a category is chosen it should only pull from options you don't currently have redeemed (pets, disguises, particles, glows) or have reclaimable (plushies), similar to how Creative's cosmetic crate works. Then you can start pulling duplicates once you have all the available options in that category. This way it's still possible to roll a category you've "completed" before you have every cosmetic and not end up with a flat number of keys where you're guaranteed to have every reward, to keep the more gambling aspect the server seems to want with the crate, while still making it more realistic to get specific rewards.

I think these changes would make the crate a lot more realistic to open, and would result in people being a lot happier to open it as I think it's fallen quite flat with it's current implementation.

1 post

Sign in to join the conversation.